| 8 | DC de Boorder | Otago v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2009/10 |
| 7 | RM Schofield | Central Districts v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1964/65 |
| 7 | Wasim Bari | Pakistan v New Zealand | Eden Park, Auckland | 1978/79 |
| 7 | BA Young | Northern Districts v Canterbury | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1986/87 |
| 7 | IDS Smith | New Zealand v Sri Lanka | Trust Bank Park, Hamilton | 1990/91 |
| 7 | MG Croy | Otago v Auckland | Colin Maiden Park, Auckland | 2001/02 |
| 7 | BBJ Griggs | Central Districts v Northern Districts | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2007/08 |
| 6 | LW Downes | Central Districts v Canterbury | Trafalgar Park, Nelson | 1975/76 |
| 6 | RH Vance | Wellington v Otago | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1977/78 |
| 6 | PR Downton | England XI v Otago | Carisbrook, Dunedin | 1977/78 |
| 6 | LK Germon | Canterbury v Northern Districts | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1992/93 |
| 6 | AC Parore | New Zealand A v Pakistan A | WestpacTrust Park, Hamilton | 1998/99 |
| 6 | RA Young | Auckland v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2002/03 |
| 6 | GJ Hopkins | Otago v Canterbury | University Oval, Dunedin | 2004/05 |
| 6 | PD McGlashan | Northern Districts v Auckland | Eden Park Outer Oval, Auckland | 2006/07 |
| 6 | BJ Watling | Northern Districts v Central Districts | Harry Barker Reserve, Gisborne | 2006/07 |
| 6 | MS Dhoni | India v New Zealand | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2008/09 |
| 6 | PD McGlashan | Northern Districts v Central Districts | Cobham Oval (New), Whangarei | 2009/10 |
| 6 | PD McGlashan | Northern Districts v Central Districts | Cobham Oval (New), Whangarei | 2009/10 |
| 6 | J Austin-Smellie | Wellington v Central Districts | Nelson Park, Napier | 2010/11 |
| 6 | Adnan Akmal | Pakistan v New Zealand | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2010/11 |
| 6 | PD McGlashan | Northern Districts v Auckland | Colin Maiden Park, Auckland | 2010/11 |
| 6 | GJ Hopkins | Auckland v Northern Districts | Cobham Oval (New), Whangarei | 2011/12 |
| 6 | GJ Hopkins | Auckland v Otago | Colin Maiden Park, Auckland | 2011/12 |
| 6 | DC de Boorder | Otago v Northern Districts | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2012/13 |
| 6 | L Ronchi | Wellington v Northern Districts | Karori Park, Wellington | 2012/13 |
| 6 | BJ Watling | New Zealand v India | Eden Park, Auckland | 2013/14 |
| 6 | CFK van Wyk | Central Districts v Otago | Nelson Park, Napier | 2014/15 |
| 6 | BJ Watling | New Zealand v Sri Lanka | University Oval, Dunedin | 2015/16 |
| 6 | B Cachopa | Auckland v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2015/16 |
| 6 | L Ronchi | Wellington v Canterbury | Hagley Oval, Christchurch | 2016/17 |
| 6 | TA Blundell | Wellington v Canterbury | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2017/18 |
| 6 | BJ Horne | Auckland v Central Districts | Eden Park Outer Oval, Auckland | 2018/19 |
| 6 | TA Blundell | Wellington v Northern Districts | Cello Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2022/23 |
| 6 | MW Chu | Otago v Central Districts | Fitzherbert Park, Palmerston North | 2022/23 |
| 6 | CD Fletcher | Canterbury v Wellington | MainPower Oval, Rangiora | 2022/23 |
| 5 | AE Dewes | Auckland v Canterbury | Auckland Domain, Auckland | 1883/84 |
| 5 | JT Ward | South Island v North Island | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1957/58 |
| 5 | EC Petrie | Northern Districts v Otago | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 1960/61 |
| 5 | TG McMahon | Wellington v Otago | Carisbrook, Dunedin | 1960/61 |
| 5 | JM Parks | England v New Zealand | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1965/66 |
| 5 | JT Ward | Canterbury XI v New Zealand XI | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1967/68 |
| 5 | RI Harford | New Zealand v India | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1967/68 |
| 5 | KJ Wadsworth | New Zealand v Pakistan | Eden Park, Auckland | 1972/73 |
| 5 | RW Marsh | Australia v New Zealand | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1973/74 |
| 5 | KJ Wadsworth | Canterbury v Otago | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1974/75 |
| 5 | LW Downes | Central Districts v Wellington | Queen Elizabeth Park, Masterton | 1975/76 |
| 5 | KJ Wadsworth | Canterbury v Northern Districts | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1975/76 |
| 5 | SMH Kirmani | India v New Zealand | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1975/76 |
| 5 | RW Marsh | Australia v New Zealand | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1976/77 |
| 5 | BD Ritchie | Canterbury v Otago | Logan Park, Dunedin | 1979/80 |
| 5 | WK Lees | New Zealand v Sri Lanka | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1982/83 |
| 5 | AW Hart | Canterbury v Northern Districts | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1983/84 |
| 5 | EB McSweeney | Wellington v Central Districts | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1983/84 |
| 5 | EB McSweeney | Wellington v Canterbury | Dudley Park, Rangiora | 1984/85 |
| 5 | IDS Smith | Central Districts v Northern Districts | Pukekura Park, New Plymouth | 1984/85 |
| 5 | EB McSweeney | Wellington v Auckland | Eden Park, Auckland | 1984/85 |
| 5 | LK Germon | Canterbury v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1988/89 |
| 5 | IDS Smith | Auckland v Northern Districts | Eden Park, Auckland | 1988/89 |
| 5 | PJ Kelly | Auckland v Northern Districts | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 1988/89 |
| 5 | AC Parore | Auckland v Otago | Carisbrook, Dunedin | 1988/89 |
| 5 | TE Blain | Central Districts v Auckland | Eden Park, Auckland | 1990/91 |
| 5 | BA Young | Northern Districts v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1990/91 |
| 5 | HP Tillakaratne | Sri Lanka v New Zealand | Trust Bank Park, Hamilton | 1990/91 |
| 5 | IDS Smith | New Zealand v Sri Lanka | Eden Park, Auckland | 1990/91 |
| 5 | IDS Smith | Auckland v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1990/91 |
| 5 | LK Germon | Canterbury v Central Districts | Burnside Park, Christchurch | 1991/92 |
| 5 | BA Young | Northern Districts v Otago | Trust Bank Park, Hamilton | 1991/92 |
| 5 | EB McSweeney | Wellington v Central Districts | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1991/92 |
| 5 | AC Parore | New Zealand v England | Eden Park, Auckland | 1991/92 |
| 5 | JM Mills | Auckland v Central Districts | Eden Park, Auckland | 1992/93 |
| 5 | AC Parore | Auckland v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1992/93 |
| 5 | TE Blain | Central Districts v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1992/93 |
| 5 | SA Robinson | Otago v Canterbury | Carisbrook, Dunedin | 1992/93 |
| 5 | LK Germon | Canterbury v Auckland | Dudley Park, Rangiora | 1993/94 |
| 5 | Rashid Latif | Pakistan v New Zealand | Eden Park, Auckland | 1993/94 |
| 5 | RG Hart | Northern Districts v Canterbury | Trust Bank Park, Hamilton | 1994/95 |
| 5 | LK Germon | Canterbury v Otago | Centennial Park, Oamaru | 1994/95 |
| 5 | GR Baker | Wellington v Central Districts | McLean Park, Napier | 1994/95 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Wellington v Otago | Carisbrook, Dunedin | 1995/96 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Wellington v Otago | Carisbrook, Dunedin | 1995/96 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Wellington v Central Districts | Trafalgar Park, Nelson | 1995/96 |
| 5 | MEL Lane | Canterbury v Otago | Lancaster Park, Christchurch | 1995/96 |
| 5 | LK Germon | Canterbury v Northern Districts | Dudley Park, Rangiora | 1997/98 |
| 5 | LK Germon | Canterbury v Central Districts | Fitzherbert Park, Palmerston North | 1997/98 |
| 5 | AC Gilchrist | Australia v New Zealand | WestpacTrust Park, Hamilton | 1999/00 |
| 5 | AC Gilchrist | Australia v New Zealand | WestpacTrust Park, Hamilton | 1999/00 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Wellington v Otago | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2000/01 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Wellington v Auckland | Cornwall Park, Auckland | 2000/01 |
| 5 | AC Parore | New Zealand v Pakistan | Eden Park, Auckland | 2000/01 |
| 5 | RG Hart | Northern Districts v Auckland | WestpacTrust Park, Hamilton | 2001/02 |
| 5 | GA Howell | Wellington v Northern Districts | WestpacTrust Park, Hamilton | 2001/02 |
| 5 | GJ Hopkins | Canterbury v Auckland | Eden Park, Auckland | 2001/02 |
| 5 | RG Hart | Northern Districts v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2001/02 |
| 5 | JS Foster | England v New Zealand | Jade Stadium, Christchurch | 2001/02 |
| 5 | RA Young | Auckland v Central Districts | Colin Maiden Park, Auckland | 2002/03 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | Canterbury v Northern Districts | Hagley Oval, Christchurch | 2003/04 |
| 5 | GJ Hopkins | Otago v Central Districts | Pukekura Park, New Plymouth | 2003/04 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | Northern Districts v Central Districts | McLean Park, Napier | 2004/05 |
| 5 | GJ Hopkins | Otago v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2004/05 |
| 5 | PD McGlashan | Northern Districts v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2004/05 |
| 5 | MHW Papps | Canterbury v Northern Districts | Harry Barker Reserve, Gisborne | 2004/05 |
| 5 | GJ Hopkins | Otago v Wellington | Queenstown Events Centre, Queenstown | 2004/05 |
| 5 | BBJ Griggs | Central Districts v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2005/06 |
| 5 | GJ Hopkins | Otago v Northern Districts | University Oval, Dunedin | 2005/06 |
| 5 | RA Young | Auckland v Wellington | Eden Park Outer Oval, Auckland | 2005/06 |
| 5 | BBJ Griggs | Central Districts v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2006/07 |
| 5 | PD McGlashan | Northern Districts v Wellington | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2006/07 |
| 5 | CFK van Wyk | Canterbury v Auckland | Eden Park Outer Oval, Auckland | 2006/07 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | New Zealand v England | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2007/08 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | Northern Districts v Central Districts | McLean Park, Napier | 2007/08 |
| 5 | CFK van Wyk | Canterbury v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2007/08 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Wellington v Northern Districts | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2008/09 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | New Zealand v West Indies | McLean Park, Napier | 2008/09 |
| 5 | CFK van Wyk | Canterbury v Central Districts | MainPower Oval, Rangiora | 2008/09 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Wellington v Northern Districts | Cobham Oval (New), Whangarei | 2008/09 |
| 5 | CFK van Wyk | Canterbury v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2009/10 |
| 5 | PD McGlashan | Northern Districts v Wellington | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2009/10 |
| 5 | BB McCullum | New Zealand v Pakistan | McLean Park, Napier | 2009/10 |
| 5 | CFK van Wyk | Canterbury v Northern Districts | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2009/10 |
| 5 | RA Young | Auckland v Wellington | Colin Maiden Park, Auckland | 2009/10 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Wellington v Northern Districts | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2009/10 |
| 5 | PD McGlashan | Northern Districts v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2009/10 |
| 5 | CJ Nevin | Wellington v Central Districts | McLean Park, Napier | 2009/10 |
| 5 | OG Ivins | Northern Districts v Otago | Queenstown Events Centre, Queenstown | 2010/11 |
| 5 | PD McGlashan | Northern Districts v Otago | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2010/11 |
| 5 | GJ Hopkins | Auckland v Canterbury | Colin Maiden Park, Auckland | 2010/11 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | Northern Districts v Canterbury | MainPower Oval, Rangiora | 2011/12 |
| 5 | DC de Boorder | Otago v Wellington | University Oval, Dunedin | 2011/12 |
| 5 | BS Smith | Central Districts v Northern Districts | Harry Barker Reserve, Gisborne | 2012/13 |
| 5 | GJ Hopkins | Auckland v Canterbury | Eden Park Outer Oval, Auckland | 2012/13 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | Northern Districts v Canterbury | Hagley Oval, Christchurch | 2012/13 |
| 5 | MJ Prior | England v New Zealand | Eden Park, Auckland | 2012/13 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | New Zealand v West Indies | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2013/14 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | New Zealand v India | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2013/14 |
| 5 | GJ Hopkins | Auckland v Otago | University Oval, Dunedin | 2013/14 |
| 5 | B Cachopa | Auckland v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2014/15 |
| 5 | B Cachopa | Auckland v Otago | Colin Maiden Park, Auckland | 2014/15 |
| 5 | B Cachopa | Auckland v Northern Districts | Bay Oval, Mount Maunganui | 2015/16 |
| 5 | DC de Boorder | Otago v Northern Districts | University Oval, Dunedin | 2015/16 |
| 5 | B Cachopa | Auckland v Otago | University Oval, Dunedin | 2015/16 |
| 5 | CD Fletcher | Canterbury v Wellington | Hagley Oval, Christchurch | 2015/16 |
| 5 | CD Fletcher | Canterbury v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2015/16 |
| 5 | Imrul Kayes | Bangladesh v New Zealand | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2016/17 |
| 5 | Q de Kock | South Africa v New Zealand | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2016/17 |
| 5 | TL Seifert | Northern Districts v Wellington | Seddon Park, Hamilton | 2017/18 |
| 5 | DC de Boorder | Otago v Auckland | Eden Park Outer Oval, Auckland | 2017/18 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | Northern Districts v Auckland | Eden Park Outer Oval, Auckland | 2017/18 |
| 5 | JM Bairstow | England v New Zealand | Hagley Oval, Christchurch | 2017/18 |
| 5 | BJ Watling | New Zealand v Sri Lanka | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2018/19 |
| 5 | D Cleaver | Central Districts v Northern Districts | McLean Park, Napier | 2018/19 |
| 5 | D Cleaver | Central Districts v Northern Districts | McLean Park, Napier | 2019/20 |
| 5 | D Cleaver | Central Districts v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2019/20 |
| 5 | TA Blundell | Wellington v Canterbury | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2020/21 |
| 5 | PD Bocock | Northern Districts v Otago | University Oval, Dunedin | 2020/21 |
| 5 | CR McLachlan | Wellington v Canterbury | Cello Basin Reserve, Wellington | 2021/22 |
| 5 | CR McLachlan | Wellington v Canterbury | MainPower Oval, Rangiora | 2023/24 |
| 5 | PD Bocock | Northern Districts v Central Districts | Bay Oval, Mount Maunganui | 2023/24 |
| 5 | AT Carey | Australia v New Zealand | Hagley Oval, Christchurch | 2023/24 |
| 5 | AT Carey | Australia v New Zealand | Hagley Oval, Christchurch | 2023/24 |
| 5 | D Cleaver | Central Districts v Auckland | McLean Park, Napier | 2023/24 |
| 5 | D Cleaver | Central Districts v Otago | McLean Park, Napier | 2023/24 |