| 8 | MS Sinclair | Central Districts v Auckland |
| 8 | MS Sinclair | Central Districts v Otago |
| 7 | PG Fulton | Canterbury v Otago |
| 6 | RA Jones | Auckland v Central Districts |
| 6 | TG McIntosh | Auckland v Canterbury |
| 6 | HD Rutherford | Otago v Central Districts |
| 6 | KS Williamson | New Zealand v South Africa |
| 6 | GR Hay | Central Districts v Otago |
| 5 | WA Hadlee | Canterbury v Otago |
| 5 | B Sutcliffe | Otago v Auckland |
| 5 | RH Vance | Wellington v Central Districts |
| 5 | DJ White | Northern Districts v Central Districts |
| 5 | MJ Greatbatch | Central Districts v Canterbury |
| 5 | CZ Harris | Canterbury v Central Districts |
| 5 | MD Bell | Wellington v Central Districts |
| 5 | MD Bell | Wellington v Canterbury |
| 5 | MHW Papps | Canterbury v Central Districts |
| 5 | MHW Papps | Canterbury v Auckland |
| 5 | CD Cumming | Otago v Northern Districts |
| 5 | CD Cumming | Otago v Canterbury |
| 5 | PJ Ingram | Central Districts v Canterbury |
| 5 | NR Parlane | Wellington v Auckland |
| 5 | MS Sinclair | Central Districts v Northern Districts |
| 5 | DR Flynn | Northern Districts v Otago |
| 5 | JM How | Central Districts v Otago |
| 5 | TG McIntosh | Auckland v Otago |
| 5 | DR Flynn | Northern Districts v Wellington |
| 5 | BJ Watling | Northern Districts v Otago |
| 5 | JA Raval | Auckland v Central Districts |
| 5 | C Munro | Auckland v Otago |
| 5 | LJ Woodcock | Wellington v Auckland |
| 5 | GR Hay | Central Districts v Canterbury |
| 5 | B Popli | Northern Districts v Central Districts |
| 4 | FP O'Brien | Canterbury v Otago |
| 4 | WM Wallace | Auckland v Canterbury |
| 4 | VJ Scott | Auckland v Otago |
| 4 | B Sutcliffe | Otago v Canterbury |
| 4 | JR Reid | Wellington v Auckland |
| 4 | GT Dowling | Canterbury v Central Districts |
| 4 | GM Turner | Otago v Wellington |
| 4 | JM Parker | Northern Districts v Central Districts |
| 4 | MD Crowe | Central Districts v Canterbury |
| 4 | RH Vance | Wellington v Northern Districts |
| 4 | BA Edgar | Wellington v Otago |
| 4 | BA Edgar | Wellington v Central Districts |
| 4 | MD Crowe | Central Districts v Northern Districts |
| 4 | KR Rutherford | Otago v Central Districts |
| 4 | DN Patel | Auckland v Northern Districts |
| 4 | MH Richardson | Otago v Central Districts |
| 4 | ME Parlane | Northern Districts v Wellington |
| 4 | JG Myburgh | Canterbury v Central Districts |
| 4 | MD Bell | Wellington v Northern Districts |
| 4 | MD Bell | Wellington v Auckland |
| 4 | CD Cumming | Otago v Auckland |
| 4 | JAH Marshall | Northern Districts v Canterbury |
| 4 | MHW Papps | Canterbury v Otago |
| 4 | PJ Ingram | Central Districts v Northern Districts |
| 4 | TG McIntosh | Auckland v Wellington |
| 4 | CD Cumming | Otago v Central Districts |
| 4 | KS Williamson | Northern Districts v Wellington |
| 4 | NT Broom | Otago v Northern Districts |
| 4 | JD Ryder | Wellington v Central Districts |
| 4 | JEC Franklin | Wellington v Otago |
| 4 | SJ Murdoch | Wellington v Central Districts |
| 4 | DR Flynn | Northern Districts v Central Districts |
| 4 | SJ Murdoch | Wellington v Canterbury |
| 4 | C Munro | Auckland v Central Districts |
| 4 | NT Broom | Otago v Auckland |
| 4 | MHW Papps | Wellington v Otago |
| 4 | LRPL Taylor | New Zealand v West Indies |
| 4 | HD Rutherford | Otago v Northern Districts |
| 4 | KS Williamson | New Zealand v Sri Lanka |
| 4 | TWM Latham | Canterbury v Wellington |
| 4 | TWM Latham | Canterbury v Central Districts |
| 4 | TC Bruce | Central Districts v Northern Districts |
| 4 | TC Bruce | Central Districts v Auckland |
| 4 | SM Solia | Auckland v Wellington |
| 4 | BD Schmulian | Central Districts v Northern Districts |
| 4 | KS Williamson | New Zealand v England |
| 4 | JA Raval | Northern Districts v Central Districts |
| 4 | HM Nicholls | Canterbury v Auckland |
| 4 | HR Cooper | Northern Districts v Auckland |
| 4 | JF Carter | Northern Districts v Otago |
| 4 | NF Kelly | Wellington v Otago |
The list shows 84 occurrences of 4 or more