| 5 | TW Jarvis | Pakistanis v New Zealand Cricket Council President's XI | 1964/65 | f25639 |
| 5 | GN Edwards | Otago v Central Districts | 1979/80 | f32895 |
| 5 | MW Douglas | Otago v Central Districts | 1988/89 | f37924 |
| 5 | JM How | Canterbury v Central Districts | 2003/04 | f47647 |
| 4 | BL Jones | Auckland v Central Districts | 1954/55 | f20757 |
| 4 | EA Watson | Central Districts v Otago | 1957/58 | f22091 |
| 4 | JT Sparling | Central Districts v Auckland | 1968/69 | f27599 |
| 4 | ML Ryan | Wellington v Central Districts | 1969/70 | f28046 |
| 4 | HJ Howarth | Central Districts v Auckland | 1975/76 | f30980 |
| 4 | DH Payton | Auckland v Central Districts | 1975/76 | f30980 |
| 4 | MHW Papps | Central Districts v Canterbury | 2003/04 | f47647 |
| 4 | NR Parlane | Central Districts v Wellington | 2007/08 | f50752 |