| Main FC | Otago (1957/58-1963/64) |
| Canterbury (1964/65) | |
| Other FC | South Island (1957/58) |
| The Rest (1957/58) | |
| Plunket Shield | Otago (1957/58-1963/64) |
| Canterbury (1964/65) | |
| Miscellaneous | Otago Under-20s (1953/54-1956/57) |
| Otago (1954/55-1961/62) | |
| Dunedin Metropolitan (1957/58-1963/64) | |
| LD Smith's XI (1957/58-1963/64) | |
| Otago XI (1963/64) | |
| Canterbury XI (1964/65-1965/66) | |
| Canterbury B (1965/66) |