| Main FC | Trinidad (1899/00-1905/06) |
| | Northamptonshire (1907-1914) |
| | Auckland (1917/18-1925/26) |
| Other FC | West Indies (1901/02-1904/05) |
| | West Indians (1906) |
| | HDG Leveson-Gower's XI (1909) |
| | Gentlemen (1909-1914) |
| | SH Cochrane's XI (1909) |
| | Marylebone Cricket Club (1910/11-1912/13) |
| | England XI (1912) |
| | Gentlemen of England (1912) |
| | The Rest (1913-1914) |
| | New Zealand (1920/21-1923/24) |
| County Championship | Northamptonshire (1909-1914) |
| Plunket Shield | Auckland (1918/19-1925/26) |
| Miscellaneous | Queen's Park (1904/05) |
| | West Indians (1906) |
| | SH Cochrane's XI (1907) |
| | Northamptonshire (1909-1914) |
| | Marylebone Cricket Club (1910/11) |