| 4 | GJ McDougall | Middlesex Cricket Board v Cambridgeshire | 2002 | a14553 |
| 4 | BJM Scott | Yorkshire v Middlesex | 2004 | a16027 |
| 3 | P Farbrace | Kent v Middlesex | 1991 | a7061 |
| 3 | KM Krikken | Middlesex v Derbyshire | 1999 | a12071 |
| 3 | RC Russell | Middlesex v Gloucestershire | 2002 | a14406 |
| 3 | BJM Scott | Northamptonshire v Middlesex | 2007 | a18394 |