| 6 | MJ Prior | South Africa v England | 2008 | a19138 |
| 5 | DL Murray | Lancashire v Nottinghamshire | 1968 | a107 |
| 5 | CMW Read | Gloucestershire v Nottinghamshire | 2001 | a13527 |
| 5 | CMW Read | Sussex v Nottinghamshire | 2004 | a15921 |
| 5 | JW Blake | Nottinghamshire v Surrey | 2025 | a31868 |
| 5 | OB Cox | Middlesex v Leicestershire | 2026 | a32624 |