| 4 | GD Elliott | Kent v Surrey | 2009 | tt1321 |
| 4 | D Ferreira | London Spirit Men v Oval Invincibles Men | 2024 | tt14035 |
| 3 | SJ Benn | Australia v West Indies | 2009 | tt1283 |
| 3 | KP Pietersen | Kent v Surrey | 2012 | tt3036 |
| 3 | DJ Bravo | Hampshire v Surrey | 2016 | tt5750 |
| 3 | SC Meaker | Middlesex v Surrey | 2017 | tt6348 |
| 3 | DA Miller | Surrey v Glamorgan | 2017 | tt6390 |
| 3 | T Westley | Surrey v Essex | 2019 | tt8102 |
| 3 | R Clarke | Kent v Surrey | 2020 | tt9017 |
| 3 | J Overton | Kent v Surrey | 2020 | tt9041 |
| 3 | CA Ingram | Manchester Originals Men v Oval Invincibles Men | 2021 | tt9847 |
| 3 | J Overton | Yorkshire v Surrey | 2022 | tt11088 |
| 3 | C Overton | Surrey v Somerset | 2023 | tt12408 |
| 3 | WG Jacks | Manchester Originals Men v Oval Invincibles Men | 2023 | tt12527 |
| 3 | TA Lammonby | Surrey v Somerset | 2024 | tt13713 |
| 3 | JJ Roy | Sussex v Surrey | 2024 | tt13733 |
| 3 | FJ Hudson-Prentice | Surrey v Sussex | 2024 | tt13733 |
| 3 | TS Rogers | Surrey v Kent | 2024 | tt13905 |
| 3 | LJ Evans | Birmingham Phoenix Men v Southern Brave Men | 2024 | tt14054 |