| 6 | TW Oates | Leicestershire v Nottinghamshire | 1907 | f7118 |
| 6 | HG Davies | Leicestershire v Glamorgan | 1939 | f16714 |
| 5 | HR Butt | Leicestershire v Sussex | 1901 | f5579 |
| 5 | H Strudwick | Leicestershire v Surrey | 1909 | f7835 |
| 5 | JC Hubble | Leicestershire v Kent | 1922 | f10173 |
| 5 | TE Sidwell | Oxford University v Leicestershire | 1922 | f10256 |
| 5 | TE Sidwell | Essex v Leicestershire | 1924 | f11068 |
| 5 | JC Hubble | Leicestershire v Kent | 1925 | f11174 |
| 5 | D Sullivan | Leicestershire v Glamorgan | 1926 | f11499 |
| 5 | B Lilley | Leicestershire v Nottinghamshire | 1928 | f12329 |
| 5 | T Every | Leicestershire v Glamorgan | 1932 | f13879 |
| 5 | GO Dawkes | Gloucestershire v Leicestershire | 1938 | f16159 |