| 5 | H Whitehead | Sussex v Leicestershire | 1912 | f8604 |
| 4 | CJ Kortright | Leicestershire v Essex | 1901 | f5602 |
| 4 | AE Knight | Nottinghamshire v Leicestershire | 1901 | f5659 |
| 4 | CB Fry | Leicestershire v Sussex | 1903 | f6062 |
| 4 | RT Crawford | Derbyshire v Leicestershire | 1904 | f6401 |
| 4 | EG Hayes | Leicestershire v Surrey | 1906 | f6878 |
| 4 | FC Holland | Leicestershire v Surrey | 1908 | f7393 |
| 4 | WMF Turner | Leicestershire v Essex | 1914 | f9053 |
| 4 | C Hallows | Leicestershire v Lancashire | 1920 | f9607 |
| 4 | HA Smith | New Zealanders v Leicestershire | 1927 | f11978 |
| 4 | RC Blunt | Leicestershire v New Zealanders | 1927 | f11978 |
| 4 | HA Smith | Essex v Leicestershire | 1928 | f12268 |
| 4 | WH Ashdown | Leicestershire v Kent | 1931 | f13479 |
| 4 | JW Hearne | Leicestershire v Middlesex | 1932 | f13921 |
| 4 | NWD Yardley | Leicestershire v Yorkshire | 1938 | f16289 |