| 6 | MS Dhoni | England v India | 2007 | a18368 |
| 5 | RW Marsh | England v Australia | 1981 | a2987 |
| 5 | WK Hegg | Yorkshire v Lancashire | 1998 | a11347 |
| 5 | RJ Blakey | Warwickshire v Yorkshire | 1999 | a12132 |
| 5 | GL Brophy | Sussex v Yorkshire | 2009 | a19765 |
| 5 | Anamul Haque | Yorkshire v Bangladesh A | 2013 | a22746 |
| 5 | TR Ambrose | Yorkshire v Warwickshire | 2018 | a26417 |