| 5 | AHS Clark | Northamptonshire v Somerset | 1930 | f13171 |
| 5 | BW Bellamy | Essex v Northamptonshire | 1933 | f14294 |
| 5 | A Long | Northamptonshire v Surrey | 1971 | f28874 |
| 4 | D Sullivan | Northamptonshire v Glamorgan | 1926 | f11677 |
| 4 | BW Bellamy | Surrey v Northamptonshire | 1929 | f12712 |
| 4 | JG Navle | Northamptonshire v Indians | 1932 | f13857 |
| 4 | HJH Lamb | Warwickshire v Northamptonshire | 1934 | f14662 |
| 4 | WT Luckes | Northamptonshire v Somerset | 1936 | f15338 |
| 4 | WFF Price | Northamptonshire v Middlesex | 1937 | f15823 |
| 4 | K Fiddling | Somerset v Northamptonshire | 1948 | f18005 |
| 4 | H Yarnold | Northamptonshire v Worcestershire | 1949 | f18385 |
| 4 | JT Murray | Northamptonshire v Middlesex | 1960 | f23372 |
| 4 | R Julian | Northamptonshire v Leicestershire | 1965 | f25845 |
| 4 | JT Murray | Northamptonshire v Middlesex | 1969 | f27844 |
| 4 | LA Johnson | Middlesex v Northamptonshire | 1969 | f27844 |