| 6 | GNG Kirby | Cambridge University v Surrey | 1949 | f18366 |
| 5 | MG Griffith | Surrey v Cambridge University | 1963 | f24815 |
| 5 | A Long | Essex v Surrey | 1968 | f27287 |
| 5 | CJ Richards | Sussex v Surrey | 1987 | f37055 |
| 5 | CJ Richards | Sussex v Surrey | 1987 | f37055 |
| 5 | RC Russell | Surrey v Gloucestershire | 1991 | f39421 |
| 5 | JN Batty | Northamptonshire v Surrey | 2001 | f45941 |
| 5 | JN Batty | Essex v Surrey | 2009 | f51656 |
| 5 | JS Foster | Surrey v Essex | 2017 | f57926 |