| 5 | EA Bedser | Oxford University v Surrey | 1950 | f18757 |
| 5 | MJ Stewart | Oxford University v Surrey | 1957 | f21808 |
| 5 | MJ Edwards | Leicestershire v Surrey | 1967 | f26760 |
| 5 | R Clarke | Worcestershire v Surrey | 2007 | f50147 |
| 5 | VS Solanki | Kent v Surrey | 2014 | f55713 |
| 4 | AV Bedser | Sussex v Surrey | 1947 | f17558 |
| 4 | WS Surridge | Hampshire v Surrey | 1950 | f18767 |
| 4 | KG Suttle | Surrey v Sussex | 1953 | f20093 |
| 4 | GAR Lock | Hampshire v Surrey | 1954 | f20509 |
| 4 | PJ Loader | Hampshire v Surrey | 1957 | f21818 |
| 4 | MSW Burton | Surrey v Oxford University | 1970 | f28270 |
| 4 | GRJ Roope | Worcestershire v Surrey | 1971 | f28743 |
| 4 | GRJ Roope | Hampshire v Surrey | 1972 | f29241 |
| 4 | Younis Ahmed | Somerset v Surrey | 1976 | f31077 |
| 4 | RS Madugalle | Oxford University v Sri Lankans | 1979 | f32616 |
| 4 | AR Butcher | Sussex v Surrey | 1981 | f33662 |
| 4 | KT Medlycott | Kent v Surrey | 1988 | f37614 |
| 4 | MA Lynch | Kent v Surrey | 1990 | f38824 |
| 4 | MA Butcher | Leicestershire v Surrey | 2000 | f45204 |
| 4 | AD Brown | Yorkshire v Surrey | 2002 | f46701 |
| 4 | AEN Riley | Surrey v Kent | 2014 | f55713 |
| 4 | RS Patel | Sri Lanka Cricket Development XI v Surrey | 2022 | f60870 |