| 5-28 | ACS Pigott | Sussex v Surrey | 1982 | a3435 |
| 5-28 | JE Burke | Surrey v Derbyshire | 2015 | a24192 |
| 5-35 | IG Holland | Hampshire v Surrey | 2023 | a30164 |
| 5-38 | C Forbes | Nottinghamshire v Surrey | 1973 | a1052 |
| 5-44 | AJ Hollioake | Surrey v Sussex | 1996 | a9970 |
| 5-45 | Yasir Arafat | Surrey v Warwickshire | 2011 | a21429 |
| 5-45 | R Lord | Nottinghamshire v Surrey | 2024 | a31039 |