| 5 | AG Paul | Derbyshire v Lancashire | 1897 | f4636 |
| 4 | CA Absolom | Derbyshire v Kent | 1877 | f2037 |
| 4 | E Lockwood | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1879 | f2244 |
| 4 | R Abel | Derbyshire v Surrey | 1884 | f2736 |
| 4 | F Davidson | Leicestershire v Derbyshire | 1898 | f4924 |
| 4 | AO Jones | Derbyshire v Nottinghamshire | 1902 | f5900 |
| 4 | FSG Calthorpe | Derbyshire v Warwickshire | 1927 | f12088 |
| 4 | JG Langridge | Derbyshire v Sussex | 1933 | f14320 |
| 4 | DB Carr | Lancashire v Derbyshire | 1957 | f21875 |
| 4 | DB Carr | Kent v Derbyshire | 1958 | f22428 |
| 4 | C Lee | Lancashire v Derbyshire | 1964 | f25320 |
| 4 | MH Page | Middlesex v Derbyshire | 1967 | f26907 |
| 4 | M Hendrick | Northamptonshire v Derbyshire | 1977 | f31733 |
| 4 | DS Steele | Worcestershire v Derbyshire | 1979 | f32716 |
| 4 | G Cook | Derbyshire v Northamptonshire | 1983 | f34709 |
| 4 | MA Taylor | Derbyshire v Australians | 1989 | f38115 |
| 4 | CJ Adams | Essex v Derbyshire | 1990 | f38879 |
| 4 | CJ Adams | Durham v Derbyshire | 1996 | f42580 |
| 4 | CJ Adams | Derbyshire v Sussex | 1999 | f44491 |
| 4 | GA Hick | Derbyshire v Worcestershire | 2005 | f48619 |
| 4 | Tamim Iqbal | England Lions v Bangladeshis | 2010 | f52438 |
| 4 | CF Hughes | Gloucestershire v Derbyshire | 2010 | f52440 |
| 4 | ME Trescothick | Derbyshire v Somerset | 2013 | f54882 |
| 4 | OP Rayner | Derbyshire v Middlesex | 2018 | f58641 |
| 4 | WL Madsen | Warwickshire v Derbyshire | 2021 | f60443 |
| 4 | JA Leaning | Derbyshire v Kent | 2021 | f60499 |