| 5 | C Lee | Lancashire v Derbyshire | 1960 | f23259 |
| 5 | DC Morgan | Glamorgan v Derbyshire | 1960 | f23428 |
| 5 | PM Walker | Derbyshire v Glamorgan | 1961 | f23720 |
| 5 | PE Russell | Pakistanis v Derbyshire | 1978 | f32048 |
| 4 | H Sutcliffe | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1929 | f12773 |
| 4 | LF Outschoorn | Derbyshire v Worcestershire | 1949 | f18331 |
| 4 | CS Elliott | Yorkshire v Derbyshire | 1952 | f19591 |
| 4 | DB Carr | Gloucestershire v Derbyshire | 1958 | f22212 |
| 4 | IR Buxton | Surrey v Derbyshire | 1965 | f25971 |
| 4 | G Miller | Kent v Derbyshire | 1979 | f32664 |
| 4 | MW Gatting | Derbyshire v Middlesex | 1983 | f34675 |
| 4 | D Byas | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1990 | f38720 |
| 4 | D Byas | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1995 | f41739 |
| 4 | CJL Rogers | Surrey v Derbyshire | 2010 | f52477 |
| 4 | WL Madsen | Middlesex v Derbyshire | 2022 | f60888 |