| 6 | WR Hammond | Surrey v Gloucestershire | 1928 | f12499 |
| 5 | BH Lyon | Leicestershire v Gloucestershire | 1933 | f14388 |
| 5 | CA Milton | Pakistanis v Gloucestershire | 1954 | f20616 |
| 5 | JM Prodger | Gloucestershire v Kent | 1961 | f23950 |
| 5 | RGA Headley | Gloucestershire v Worcestershire | 1967 | f26930 |
| 5 | GA Gooch | Gloucestershire v Essex | 1982 | f34215 |
| 5 | MCJ Ball | Yorkshire v Gloucestershire | 1994 | f41189 |
| 5 | RE Watkins | Gloucestershire v Glamorgan | 2006 | f49465 |
| 5 | JA Simpson | Gloucestershire v Middlesex | 2021 | f60468 |