| 9 | JS Foster | Gloucestershire v Essex | 2014 | f55691 |
| 9 | MS Pepper | Durham v Essex | 2024 | f62283 |
| 8 | RJ Rollins | Nottinghamshire v Essex | 1996 | f42501 |
| 8 | PA Nixon | Pakistan A v First-Class Counties Select XI | 1997 | f43202 |
| 8 | JS Foster | Nottinghamshire v Essex | 2003 | f47410 |
| 8 | JS Foster | Derbyshire v Essex | 2009 | f51562 |
| 8 | CMW Read | Essex v Nottinghamshire | 2010 | f52483 |
| 8 | JS Foster | Yorkshire v Essex | 2017 | f58038 |
| 8 | WEL Buttleman | Warwickshire v Essex | 2023 | f61609 |