| 5 | GA Hick | Essex v Worcestershire | 2005 | f48681 |
| 4 | WR Hammond | Essex v Gloucestershire | 1928 | f12418 |
| 4 | SB Hassan | Essex v Nottinghamshire | 1973 | f29793 |
| 4 | PH Edmonds | Essex v Middlesex | 1976 | f31212 |
| 4 | KS McEwan | Yorkshire v Essex | 1978 | f32131 |
| 4 | S Turner | Leicestershire v Essex | 1979 | f32581 |
| 4 | SM Gavaskar | Essex v Indians | 1979 | f32704 |
| 4 | CG Greenidge | Essex v Hampshire | 1982 | f34207 |
| 4 | JE Emburey | Essex v Middlesex | 1988 | f37585 |
| 4 | AJ Wright | Essex v Gloucestershire | 1994 | f41121 |
| 4 | IN Flanagan | Middlesex v Essex | 2000 | f45174 |
| 4 | VS Solanki | Essex v Worcestershire | 2000 | f45203 |
| 4 | BF Smith | Essex v Worcestershire | 2006 | f49421 |
| 4 | Harbhajan Singh | Leicestershire v Essex | 2012 | f54110 |
| 4 | PA Jaques | Essex v Yorkshire | 2012 | f54163 |
| 4 | SR Harmer | Warwickshire v Essex | 2024 | f62265 |