| 4 | E Bligh | Cambridge Town Club v Cambridge University | 1819 | f325 |
| 4 | RN Blaker | Marylebone Cricket Club v Cambridge University | 1843 | f624 |
| 4 | I Haggis | Cambridge University v Cambridge Town and County Club | 1844 | f652 |
| 3 | J Page | Cambridge University v Cambridge Town Club | 1820 | f331 |
| 3 | J Boning | Cambridge University v Cambridge Town Club | 1836 | f492 |
| 3 | CG Taylor | Cambridge University v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1841 | f579 |
| 3 | CT Freer | Cambridge University v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1843 | f624 |
| 3 | FW Lillywhite | Cambridge University v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1844 | f651 |
| 3 | GP Ottey | Cambridge Town and County Club v Cambridge University | 1844 | f652 |
| 3 | FJ Gruggen | Cambridge Town and County Club v Cambridge University | 1845 | f676 |
| 3 | A Walker | Cambridge Town and County Club v Cambridge University | 1847 | f734 |
| 3 | RT King | Marylebone Cricket Club v Cambridge Town and County Club | 1847 | f756 |
| 3 | T Hayward | Cambridge University v Cambridge Town Club | 1859 | f1077 |
| 3 | T Hayward | Kent v Cambridgeshire | 1861 | f1146 |
| 3 | R Iddison | Cambridgeshire v Yorkshire | 1864 | f1273 |
| 3 | J Smith | Yorkshire v Cambridgeshire | 1864 | f1273 |