| 309-6 | West Indies v Pakistan | 2016/17 | o3861 |
| 308-5 | Pakistan v West Indies | 2016/17 | o3861 |
| 303-5 | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2006/07 | o2560 |
| 282-5 | Pakistan v West Indies | 2016/17 | o3862 |
| 279-4 | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2018 | o4022 |
| 271 | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2018 | o4023 |
| 270-7 | England v West Indies | 2008/09 | o2826 |
| 268-6 | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2018 | o4023 |
| 266-7 | England v Ireland | 2006/07 | o2558 |
| 264-8 | West Indies v England | 2008/09 | o2827 |
| 263-8 | New Zealand v Ireland | 2006/07 | o2566 |
| 254-5 | Zimbabwe v West Indies | 2009/10 | o2967 |
| 252-9 | West Indies v Zimbabwe | 2009/10 | o2967 |
| 251-8 | Bangladesh v South Africa | 2006/07 | o2564 |