| 4 | DM Bravo | England v West Indies | 2014/15 | t2157 |
| 4 | JD Campbell | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2026 | t2626 |
| 3 | N Deonarine | New Zealand v West Indies | 2012 | t2050 |
| 3 | Liton Das | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2018 | t2310 |
| 3 | JO Holder | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2018 | t2310 |
| 3 | C Overton | West Indies v England | 2021/22 | t2454 |
| 3 | BA King | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2026 | t2626 |