| 4 | DC Thomas | Guyana v Leeward Islands | 2014/15 | f56200 |
| 4 | O Peters | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 2015/16 | f56951 |
| 4 | GH Vihari | West Indies A v India A | 2019 | f59557 |
| 4 | KAR Hodge | West Indies Academy v Windward Islands | 2024/25 | f62914 |
| 3 | JC Guillen | Guyana v Trinidad and Tobago | 2009/10 | f52215 |
| 3 | LR Johnson | Jamaica v Guyana | 2011/12 | f53885 |
| 3 | N Deonarine | New Zealand v West Indies | 2012 | f54102 |
| 3 | KOA Powell | Guyana v Leeward Islands | 2013/14 | f55567 |
| 3 | O Peters | Barbados v Leeward Islands | 2013/14 | f55585 |
| 3 | LR Johnson | Leeward Islands v Guyana | 2014/15 | f56200 |
| 3 | DM Bravo | England v West Indies | 2014/15 | f56356 |
| 3 | O Peters | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 2015/16 | f56951 |
| 3 | Liton Das | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2018 | f58735 |
| 3 | KOA Powell | Windward Islands v Leeward Islands | 2018/19 | f59378 |
| 3 | A Williams | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 2019/20 | f60125 |
| 3 | TR Warde | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 2019/20 | f60125 |
| 3 | AWJ Auguste | Windward Islands v West Indies Academy | 2024/25 | f62914 |