| 4 | VP Terry | Sussex v Hampshire | 1996 | f42486 |
| 4 | CJ Adams | Derbyshire v Sussex | 2001 | f45898 |
| 4 | LMP Simmons | Indians v West Indies A | 2002 | f46689 |
| 4 | APR Gidman | Sussex v Gloucestershire | 2004 | f48035 |
| 4 | CJ Adams | Hampshire v Sussex | 2008 | f50890 |
| 3 | AJ Stewart | Sussex v Surrey | 1991 | f39411 |
| 3 | DM Smith | Hampshire v Sussex | 1992 | f40007 |
| 3 | MW Gatting | Sussex v Middlesex | 1994 | f41183 |
| 3 | CWJ Athey | Middlesex v Sussex | 1994 | f41183 |
| 3 | JD Carr | Sussex v Middlesex | 1994 | f41183 |
| 3 | SL Campbell | Zimbabweans v West Indians | 2000 | f45156 |
| 3 | CJ Adams | Essex v Sussex | 2003 | f47348 |
| 3 | BC Lara | Marylebone Cricket Club v West Indians | 2004 | f48042 |
| 3 | CJ Adams | Yorkshire v Sussex | 2006 | f49433 |
| 3 | CJ Adams | Hampshire v Sussex | 2007 | f50106 |
| 3 | RR Montgomerie | Hampshire v Sussex | 2007 | f50106 |
| 3 | JHK Adams | Sussex v Hampshire | 2007 | f50106 |
| 3 | CK Kapugedera | Marylebone Cricket Club v Sri Lanka A | 2007 | f50132 |
| 3 | EC Joyce | Gloucestershire v Sussex | 2010 | f52489 |
| 3 | MJ Prior | Surrey v Sussex | 2013 | f54881 |
| 3 | HZ Finch | Leicestershire v Sussex | 2017 | f57958 |
| 3 | HZ Finch | Durham v Sussex | 2018 | f58719 |