| 5 | RB Kanhai | Combined Leeward and Windward Islands v Guyana | 1972/73 | f29499 |
| 5 | AR Percival | Leeward Islands v Guyana | 1998/99 | f44176 |
| 4 | AG Barrett | Combined Leeward and Windward Islands v Jamaica | 1970/71 | f28624 |
| 4 | IT Shillingford | Guyana v Combined Leeward and Windward Islands | 1972/73 | f29499 |
| 4 | IVA Richards | Trinidad and Tobago v Combined Leeward and Windward Islands | 1977/78 | f32002 |
| 4 | IT Shillingford | Leeward Islands v Windward Islands | 1979/80 | f32983 |
| 4 | TZ Kentish | Leeward Islands v Windward Islands | 1979/80 | f32983 |
| 4 | CB Lambert | Leeward Islands v Guyana | 1984/85 | f35642 |
| 4 | WD Phillip | Guyana v Leeward Islands | 1998/99 | f44176 |
| 4 | CL Hooper | Australia v West Indies | 1998/99 | f44354 |
| 4 | CM Tuckett | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 1999/00 | f44964 |
| 4 | KF Semple | Leeward Islands v Guyana | 2000/01 | f45544 |
| 4 | G Kirsten | West Indies v South Africa | 2000/01 | f45780 |
| 4 | ND McKenzie | West Indies v South Africa | 2000/01 | f45780 |
| 4 | DS Smith | England v West Indies | 2008/09 | f51430 |