| 4 | DJG Sammy | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2009 | t1926 |
| 4 | Mahmudullah | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2009 | t1926 |
| 3 | BC Lara | New Zealand v West Indies | 2002 | t1608 |
| 3 | Mohammad Ashraful | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2009 | t1926 |
| 3 | Tamim Iqbal | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2009 | t1926 |
| 3 | JO Holder | England v West Indies | 2021/22 | t2459 |