| 5 | VS Solanki | West Indies B v England A | 2000/01 | f45519 |
| 4 | KK Sylvester | Trinidad and Tobago v Windward Islands | 2002/03 | f47149 |
| 4 | SSW Liburd | Windward Islands v Leeward Islands | 2007/08 | f50565 |
| 4 | DJG Sammy | Bangladesh v West Indies | 2009 | f51660 |
| 4 | Mahmudullah | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2009 | f51660 |
| 4 | DB Hector | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 2012/13 | f54693 |
| 4 | T Theophile | Leeward Islands v Windward Islands | 2013/14 | f55547 |
| 4 | RO Cato | Trinidad and Tobago v Windward Islands | 2017/18 | f58439 |