| 5 | RD Jacobs | India v West Indies A | 1994/95 | a9202 |
| 4 | RL Skeete | Trinidad and Tobago v Barbados | 1979/80 | a2599 |
| 4 | D Williams | Leeward Islands v Trinidad and Tobago | 1989/90 | a6398 |
| 4 | SS Karim | West Indies v India | 1996/97 | a10443 |
| 4 | MV Boucher | West Indies v South Africa | 2000/01 | a13474 |
| 4 | PA Patel | West Indies v India | 2011 | a21391 |
| 4 | MS Dhoni | Sri Lanka v India | 2013 | a22719 |
| 4 | CAK Walton | Leeward Islands v Combined Campuses and Colleges | 2013/14 | a23240 |
| 4 | D Ramdin | Guyana v Trinidad and Tobago | 2018/19 | a26751 |