| 4 | RS Gabriel | Australians v West Indies Board President's XI | 1972/73 | f29529 |
| 4 | LG Rowe | Guyana v Jamaica | 1979/80 | f33009 |
| 3 | RGA Headley | Jamaica Invitation XI v Worcestershire | 1965/66 | f26179 |
| 3 | NE Clarke | Jamaica v Barbados | 1974/75 | f30547 |
| 3 | LNG Wright | Trinidad and Tobago v Jamaica | 1976/77 | f31414 |
| 3 | ET Willett | Jamaica v Combined Leeward and Windward Islands | 1977/78 | f31930 |
| 3 | RA Harper | Jamaica v Guyana | 1979/80 | f33009 |
| 3 | DI Kallicharran | Jamaica v Guyana | 1979/80 | f33009 |
| 3 | T Mohamed | Jamaica v Guyana | 1979/80 | f33009 |
| 3 | JB Grant | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 1995/96 | f42265 |
| 3 | LV Garrick | West Indies B v Jamaica | 2000/01 | f45648 |
| 3 | S Jackson | Trinidad and Tobago v Combined Campuses and Colleges | 2009/10 | f52198 |
| 3 | OJ Phillips | Trinidad and Tobago v Combined Campuses and Colleges | 2009/10 | f52198 |