| 16-58 | EM Dowson | RA Bennett's XI v Jamaica | 1901/02 | f5752 |
| 15-101 | DR Parry | Combined Leeward and Windward Islands v Jamaica | 1979/80 | f32996 |
| 14-71 | FW Bush | RS Lucas' XI v Jamaica | 1894/95 | f4188 |
| 13-80 | JW Toone | Jamaica v RS Lucas' XI | 1894/95 | f4190 |
| 13-114 | NO Miller | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 2017/18 | f58318 |
| 13-125 | BNL Charles | Trinidad and Tobago v Jamaica | 2023/24 | f62227 |
| 13-164 | AL Valentine | Jamaica v British Guiana | 1950/51 | f19059 |
| 12-62 | AB Cumberbatch | Trinidad v Jamaica | 1905 | f6730 |
| 12-80 | NO Perry | Jamaica v Guyana | 1988/89 | f37936 |
| 12-94 | NO Miller | Jamaica v Trinidad and Tobago | 2016/17 | f57580 |
| 12-103 | JA Warrican | West Indies A v England Lions | 2017/18 | f58533 |
| 12-131 | SP Gupte | Indians v Jamaica | 1952/53 | f19932 |
| 12-133 | NO Perry | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 2002/03 | f47135 |
| 12-149 | NO Miller | Jamaica v Trinidad and Tobago | 2018/19 | f59236 |
| 12-157 | DK Jacobs | Jamaica v Leeward Islands | 2017/18 | f58438 |