| 6 | LN Constantine | Sir J Cahn's XI v West Indies XI | 1928/29 | f12611 |
| 6 | JC Adams | England v West Indies | 1993/94 | f40993 |
| 5 | JDC Goddard | Jamaica v Barbados | 1946/47 | f17455 |
| 5 | ED Weekes | India v West Indies | 1952/53 | f19938 |
| 5 | RB Kanhai | Jamaica v British Guiana | 1965/66 | f26170 |
| 5 | MA Holding | Guyana v Jamaica | 1985/86 | f36137 |
| 5 | IVA Richards | India v West Indies | 1988/89 | f38062 |
| 5 | RC Haynes | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 1991/92 | f39801 |
| 5 | DRE Joseph | Australia v West Indies | 1998/99 | f44337 |
| 5 | BC Lara | Sri Lanka v West Indies | 2003 | f47334 |
| 5 | BC Lara | India v West Indies | 2006 | f49438 |
| 5 | LR Johnson | Jamaica v Guyana | 2011/12 | f53972 |
| 5 | KL Rahul | West Indies v India | 2016 | f57194 |
| 5 | LR Johnson | Jamaica v Guyana | 2016/17 | f57804 |
| 5 | J Blackwood | Leeward Islands v Jamaica | 2017/18 | f58442 |