| 5 | N Pothas | West Indies A v South Africa A | 2000 | a12948 |
| 5 | D Ramdin | India v West Indies | 2009 | a19837 |
| 4 | CO Browne | Leeward Islands v Barbados | 2000/01 | a13008 |
| 4 | RD Jacobs | Barbados v Leeward Islands | 2000/01 | a13008 |
| 4 | JR Murray | Jamaica v Windward Islands | 2000/01 | a13010 |
| 4 | AC Gilchrist | West Indies v Australia | 2002/03 | a15119 |
| 4 | Kamran Akmal | West Indies v Pakistan | 2006/07 | a18088 |
| 4 | BRM Taylor | Ireland v Zimbabwe | 2006/07 | a18092 |
| 4 | D Ramdin | Ireland v West Indies | 2006/07 | a18132 |
| 4 | CA Morris | Jamaica v Barbados | 2010/11 | a20834 |