| 3 | MJ Clarke | West Indies v Australia | 2002/03 | o2016 |
| 3 | SO Tikolo | New Zealand v Kenya | 2006/07 | o2544 |
| 3 | SS Cotterell | England v West Indies | 2018/19 | o4103 |
| 2 | DL Vettori | West Indies v New Zealand | 2002 | o1840 |
| 2 | RS Morton | Pakistan v West Indies | 2004/05 | o2248 |
| 2 | Shabbir Ahmed | West Indies v Pakistan | 2004/05 | o2248 |
| 2 | Younis Khan | West Indies v Pakistan | 2004/05 | o2248 |
| 2 | SO Tikolo | Canada v Kenya | 2006/07 | o2533 |
| 2 | DL Vettori | Kenya v New Zealand | 2006/07 | o2544 |
| 2 | A Flintoff | West Indies v England | 2008/09 | o2833 |
| 2 | Misbah-ul-Haq | West Indies v Pakistan | 2011 | o3153 |
| 2 | DM Bravo | Australia v West Indies | 2011/12 | o3269 |
| 2 | MEK Hussey | West Indies v Australia | 2011/12 | o3269 |
| 2 | GJ Bailey | West Indies v Australia | 2011/12 | o3269 |
| 2 | KAJ Roach | Pakistan v West Indies | 2013 | o3391 |
| 2 | Mohammad Hafeez | West Indies v Pakistan | 2013 | o3391 |
| 2 | Mohammad Hafeez | West Indies v Pakistan | 2013 | o3396 |
| 2 | Haris Sohail | West Indies v Pakistan | 2013 | o3396 |
| 2 | DJ Bravo | Pakistan v West Indies | 2013 | o3396 |
| 2 | Mohammad Nabi | West Indies v Afghanistan | 2017 | o3884 |