| 5 | GRA Langley | West Indies v Australia | 1954/55 | t405 |
| 5 | DL Murray | Pakistan v West Indies | 1976/77 | t801 |
| 4 | LEG Ames | West Indies v England | 1929/30 | t192 |
| 4 | FCM Alexander | England v West Indies | 1959/60 | t490 |
| 4 | JL Hendriks | Australia v West Indies | 1964/65 | t588 |
| 4 | RW Marsh | West Indies v Australia | 1972/73 | t720 |
| 4 | PJL Dujon | Australia v West Indies | 1990/91 | t1167 |
| 4 | CO Browne | India v West Indies | 1996/97 | t1365 |