| 5 | A Hector | Windward Islands v Leeward Islands | 1969/70 | f28081 |
| 5 | I Cadette | Australians v Windward Islands | 1983/84 | f35148 |
| 5 | JR Murray | Guyana v Windward Islands | 1991/92 | f39823 |
| 4 | TM Findlay | Marylebone Cricket Club v Windward Islands | 1967/68 | f27170 |
| 4 | RD Jacobs | Windward Islands v Leeward Islands | 1992/93 | f40456 |
| 4 | D Williams | Windward Islands v Trinidad and Tobago | 1993/94 | f40887 |