| 3 | CJ Jordan | West Indies v England | 2018/19 | itt752 |
| 3 | OF Smith | India v West Indies | 2022 | itt1718 |
| 2 | Mahmudullah | West Indies v Bangladesh | 2009 | itt117 |
| 2 | SP Narine | Afghanistan v West Indies | 2017 | itt611 |
| 2 | JE Root | West Indies v England | 2018/19 | itt751 |
| 2 | DJ Willey | West Indies v England | 2018/19 | itt751 |
| 2 | SO Hetmyer | Ireland v West Indies | 2019/20 | itt1029 |
| 2 | LMP Simmons | Ireland v West Indies | 2019/20 | itt1030 |
| 2 | CD Green | West Indies v Australia | 2025 | itt3378 |
| 2 | GJ Maxwell | West Indies v Australia | 2025 | itt3378 |
| 2 | SE Rutherford | Australia v West Indies | 2025 | itt3378 |
| 2 | JO Holder | Australia v West Indies | 2025 | itt3378 |
| 2 | MW Forde | Australia v West Indies | 2025 | itt3385 |