| 6 | MV Boucher | Pakistan v South Africa | 1997/98 | t1406 |
| 5 | HB Taber | South Africa v Australia | 1969/70 | t673 |
| 5 | DJ Richardson | India v South Africa | 1992/93 | t1206 |
| 5 | RC Russell | South Africa v England | 1995/96 | t1320 |
| 5 | K Verreynne | Sri Lanka v South Africa | 2024/25 | t2566 |