| 6 | BI Louw | KwaZulu-Natal Inland v South Western Districts | 2014/15 | f55897 |
| 5 | AJS Smith | Eastern Province v Natal | 1972/73 | f29538 |
| 5 | DM van Wyk | Dolphins v Lions | 2006/07 | f49637 |
| 5 | HG Kuhn | Dolphins v Titans | 2006/07 | f49783 |
| 5 | BG Barnes | KwaZulu-Natal Inland v KwaZulu-Natal | 2009/10 | f51784 |
| 5 | CAH Barron | Gauteng v KwaZulu-Natal Inland | 2010/11 | f52609 |
| 5 | M Gqadushe | KwaZulu-Natal v KwaZulu-Natal Inland | 2014/15 | f55944 |
| 5 | MC Christensen | KwaZulu-Natal Inland v Eastern Province | 2017/18 | f58419 |
| 5 | JF du Plessis | KwaZulu-Natal Inland v Eastern Province | 2025/26 | f63095 |