| 5 | VY Richardson | South Africa v Australia | 1935/36 | t251 |
| 4 | AW Nourse | England v South Africa | 1922/23 | t150 |
| 4 | AJ Traicos | Australia v South Africa | 1969/70 | t671 |
| 4 | HH Gibbs | West Indies v South Africa | 1998/99 | t1437 |
| 4 | SPD Smith | South Africa v Australia | 2026/27 | t2637 |