| 6 | RJ East | Griqualand West v Orange Free State | 1978/79 | f32428 |
| 6 | DJ Richardson | Orange Free State v Eastern Province | 1985/86 | f36142 |
| 5 | APC Steyn | Orange Free State v Griqualand West | 1945/46 | f16990 |
| 5 | JH Ferrandi | Orange Free State v Western Province | 1952/53 | f19847 |
| 5 | R van der Poll | Griqualand West v Orange Free State | 1959/60 | f23076 |
| 5 | AG Henderson | Border v Orange Free State | 1965/66 | f26048 |
| 5 | SD Bruce | Transvaal B v Orange Free State | 1972/73 | f29523 |
| 5 | RJ East | Griqualand West v Orange Free State | 1976/77 | f31504 |
| 5 | RJ East | Natal B v Orange Free State | 1979/80 | f32809 |