| 5 | GL Brophy | Northerns v Free State | 2000/01 | a12971 |
| 5 | MN van Wyk | Border v Free State | 2001/02 | a13788 |
| 5 | TL Tsolekile | Free State v Western Province | 2001/02 | a13866 |
| 5 | TL Tsolekile | Eagles v Cape Cobras | 2006/07 | a17641 |
| 5 | LN Mosena | North West v Free State | 2007/08 | a18765 |
| 5 | RS Second | Cape Cobras v Knights | 2016/17 | a25181 |
| 4 | SJ Palframan | Orange Free State v Border | 1991/92 | a7272 |
| 4 | PJL Radley | Griqualand West v Orange Free State | 1994/95 | a8846 |
| 4 | W Bossenger | Free State v Griqualand West | 1998/99 | a11729 |
| 4 | GL Brophy | Western Province v Free State | 1999/00 | a12463 |
| 4 | ELR Stewart | Free State v KwaZulu-Natal | 2000/01 | a13270 |
| 4 | I Mitchell | Free State v Border | 2001/02 | a13788 |
| 4 | KC Sangakkara | New Zealand v Sri Lanka | 2002/03 | a14912 |
| 4 | KO Otieno | Zimbabwe v Kenya | 2002/03 | a15000 |
| 4 | D Smit | Knights v Dolphins | 2011/12 | a21598 |
| 4 | SW Billings | South Africa A v England Lions | 2014/15 | a23986 |
| 4 | BRM Taylor | South Africa v Zimbabwe | 2018/19 | a26735 |
| 4 | WK Makwetu | Warriors v Knights | 2019/20 | a27967 |
| 4 | DA Ridgard | KwaZulu-Natal Inland v Free State | 2020/21 | a28251 |
| 4 | AT Carey | South Africa v Australia | 2023/24 | a30191 |