| 4 | DH Payton | Australians v Central Districts | 1976/77 | f31466 |
| 4 | MW Douglas | Sri Lankans v Central Districts | 1990/91 | f39209 |
| 4 | CE Eksteen | New Zealand Academy v South Africans | 1994/95 | f41654 |
| 4 | JM Aiken | South Africans v New Zealand Academy | 1994/95 | f41654 |
| 3 | FE Greenfield | Wellington v Nelson | 1891/92 | f3691 |
| 3 | DD Taylor | Central Districts v Auckland | 1956/57 | f21612 |
| 3 | AR MacGibbon | Central Districts v Canterbury | 1959/60 | f23037 |
| 3 | IB Leggat | Canterbury v Central Districts | 1959/60 | f23037 |
| 3 | RT Barber | Canterbury v Central Districts | 1959/60 | f23037 |
| 3 | DA Kinsella | Otago v Central Districts | 1962/63 | f24607 |
| 3 | IR Hampton | Canterbury v Central Districts | 1963/64 | f25126 |
| 3 | JFM Morrison | Otago v Central Districts | 1966/67 | f26612 |
| 3 | BF Hastings | Central Districts v Canterbury | 1971/72 | f28994 |
| 3 | MG Burgess | Central Districts v Auckland | 1974/75 | f30410 |
| 3 | NM Parker | Central Districts v Canterbury | 1975/76 | f30909 |
| 3 | AB Jordan | Canterbury v Central Districts | 1978/79 | f32449 |
| 3 | TB Horne | Canterbury v Central Districts | 1978/79 | f32449 |
| 3 | PE McEwan | Central Districts v Canterbury | 1982/83 | f34496 |
| 3 | MD Crowe | Northern Districts v Central Districts | 1986/87 | f36745 |
| 3 | MAWR Madurasinghe | Central Districts v Sri Lankans | 1990/91 | f39209 |
| 3 | UC Hathurusingha | Central Districts v Sri Lankans | 1990/91 | f39209 |
| 3 | JN Rhodes | New Zealand Academy v South Africans | 1994/95 | f41654 |
| 3 | MD Bailey | Central Districts v Northern Districts | 1996/97 | f42880 |
| 3 | CJM Furlong | Northern Districts v Central Districts | 1996/97 | f42880 |
| 3 | CD Garner | Northern Districts v Central Districts | 1996/97 | f42880 |