| 4 | EL Wright | Hawke's Bay v Auckland | 1894/95 | f4193 |
| 3 | S Nicholls | Hawke's Bay v Wellington | 1884/85 | f2844 |
| 3 | JE Chapman | Hawke's Bay v Wellington | 1886/87 | f3111 |
| 3 | RG Hallamore | Wellington v Hawke's Bay | 1900/01 | f5508 |
| 3 | RG Hallamore | Canterbury v Hawke's Bay | 1903/04 | f6273 |
| 3 | GE Schmoll | Hawke's Bay v Auckland | 1905/06 | f6811 |
| 3 | G Hodge | Hawke's Bay v Wellington | 1907/08 | f7359 |
| 3 | HJ Tattersall | Hawke's Bay v Auckland | 1912/13 | f8774 |