| 5 | PH Parfitt | New Zealand v England | 1962/63 | t542 |
| 5 | PH Edmonds | New Zealand v England | 1977/78 | t818 |
| 4 | GAR Lock | New Zealand v England | 1958/59 | t470 |
| 4 | AL Wadekar | New Zealand v India | 1967/68 | t631 |
| 4 | BAG Murray | India v New Zealand | 1967/68 | t631 |
| 4 | JV Coney | West Indies v New Zealand | 1986/87 | t1072 |
| 4 | MD Crowe | West Indies v New Zealand | 1986/87 | t1072 |
| 4 | AH Jones | England v New Zealand | 1987/88 | t1091 |
| 4 | RA Smith | New Zealand v England | 1991/92 | t1183 |
| 4 | N Hussain | New Zealand v England | 1996/97 | t1355 |
| 4 | NV Knight | New Zealand v England | 1996/97 | t1355 |
| 4 | SP Fleming | Sri Lanka v New Zealand | 2006/07 | t1820 |