| 5 | AE Dewes | Canterbury v Auckland | 1883/84 | f2704 |
| 5 | WNB Lusk | Wellington v Auckland | 1899/00 | f5281 |
| 5 | GE Schmoll | Canterbury v Auckland | 1903/04 | f6272 |
| 5 | RH Fox | Auckland v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1906/07 | f7072 |
| 4 | JN Fowke | New South Wales v Auckland | 1889/90 | f3457 |
| 4 | J Searle | Auckland v New South Wales | 1893/94 | f3983 |
| 4 | EL Wright | Fiji v Auckland | 1894/95 | f4168 |
| 4 | RC Niven | Auckland v Wellington | 1899/00 | f5281 |